Google is in the BUSINESS of satisfying YOUR search requests.
How does Google rank business listings? Google ranks local business listings and Google Maps results using three core factors:
1. Relevance: How well the data in Google Business Profile for a business matches what a user is searching for. Google checks the business categories, description, listed services, and attributes to see if this company-provided information matches the search query.
2. Distance: For local searches, how close the business is to the searcher's location or the location mentioned in the search term. For local searches, the business hours are also considered. If a user does not type a location, Google uses their current device location.
3. Prominence: How well-known and trusted the business is offline and online. Google evaluates this using review quantity and star ratings. It also considers online directories (citations), web links (backlinks), and overall brand recognition which includes longevity and the accumulated online content.
Google reviews are especially important because these are USER GENERATED content. Reviews (and backlinks, to a lesser degree) are what OTHERS are saying about the company - not what the company is saying about itself!
This all happens at LIGHT SPEED! Almost instantly, Google ranks every possible match to your search inquiry!
Google controls over 90% of online searches. They DEFINE how we search - and we now refer to searching as "googling". To earn YOUR repeat business, Google must provide the most useful and relevant search results.
The Google Map Pack: Top Three search results.
Your search generates "SERPs" - that is, search engine results pages.
Every search contains hundreds, usually thousands of results over many, many pages.
The "Google Map Pack" features the Top Three results for your search terms.
These TOP results claim over 60% of the resulting business!
Notice that Google reviews are the FIRST comparison listed.
The Google search listings are not based on years of experience, certifications, or any measure of SKILL.
The top Google search listings reflect expertise in MARKETING! Google Reviews are a PRIME factor!
You might not agree that this is "fair". Your business might be fully qualified to serve the customer. You might offer lower prices or faster service. I'm not here to sympathize with you. I am committed to telling you the No B.S. FACTS!
No B.S. Marketing is grounded in cold, hard facts.
The Top Three listings in the "Map Pack" fill the screen - or are featured "above the fold", using this description from print newspaper advertising.
The statistics vary, but an accurate average is that 61% of the searches direct their business to one of the Top Three listed companies in the Google Map Pack. In some cases, this percentage exceeds 75% of customers who choose one of the Top Three businesses.
This average is further skewed WITHIN the Map Pack, with the TOP company often receiving 50% of the pie, while the next two listed companies split the remaining sales and customers.
For local, "near me" searches, as many as 80% of the customers make a purchase or appointment THAT DAY!
Over 60% to the TOP THREE, less than 30% to the rest...
The news gets worse for ALL other business listings:
The FACT is that people are lazy! (This is especially true for searches on phones - which is now the MAJORITY!)
After the Top Three "Map Pack" listings, you will find the "organic listings". These consist of page after page of every other possible match for the search terms. There might be HUNDREDS of listings spread over dozens of pages.
There may also be "sponsored listings" - which include paid listings by local companies and directories like Angi, Yelp, and other paid lead services. Less than 10% of viewers click on these ads - and the advertisers pay PER CLICK, with costs of $5.00 to $10.00 per CLICK! That is, NOT per store visit, appointment, bid or sales presentation - ONLY per click through to your website!
After the Map Pack, viewers must scroll down past the paid listings to see the remaining organic listings. Then, you must use the tabs to continue to each successive page. Very few scroll down past the first page of SERPs.
There might be hundreds of search listings on dozens of pages of results. ALL these companies split less than 30% of the resulting business... NOW - do you understand why your business seems "invisible"?
FACTS about Google Reviews and Search Rankings
There is a cruel joke that asks, "Where is the best place to HIDE a dead body?"
The answer: "The second page of Google!"
This is NOT funny if your business is found on page 2, 3, or 4....
Refer back to the three primary factors in search ranking: Relevance, Location, and Prominence.
First, it is important to recognize that Google provides the GBP to every business for FREE! You can't PAY Google for higher ranking. BUT - you can COOPERATE with Google. That is, give Google the accurate data it needs to include your company in the SERPs.
Your Google Business Profile is a free, blank slate. Google will REWARD your business with higher search rankings when you do the following:
Claim and Verify: Go through the verification process on your Google Business Profile so Google can show your business as a qualified search result.
Complete All Details: Add accurate business hours, phone numbers, exact addresses, and the most specific primary and secondary categories available. Use the EXACT search terms for your services in your listing to boost relevance. See the related article about OPTIMIZING your GBP.
Collect and Reply to Reviews: Encourage customers to leave reviews and respond to every review to show active engagement. MORE reviews, CURRENT reviews, and reviews with the relevant search terms establish prominence. See the related article about automating Review Requests and Replies.
Add Visuals and Update Content CONTINUOUSLY: Upload photos, videos, blog posts, press releases, or product listings to keep your profile active. Make continuous updates and remove outdated information. See the related article about simultaneous updates to both your website AND Google Business Profile.
For LOCAL businesses: Make sure that your listing includes EVERY location that you serve - and none that you don't. See the related article about GUARANTEEING that your website and GBP share identical data.
Also note that Google will penalize your search rankings when you DON'T cooperate, don't update your GBP, or include inaccurate information. You are effectively damaging Google's product: accurate search results.
The Google Map Pack displays the Top Three search results based on Relevance, Location, and Prominence.
For local searches, businesses closest to the customer earn Prominence - IF they are open at the moment. For service providers covering entire states or regions, the other factors below have higher values.
The other qualifications include:
1. The accuracy and completeness of the GBP - as discussed above.
2. The QUANTITY and QUALITY of reviews for the business.
3. The match of every detail on your website and social media to the GBP data. This goes beyond the simple name, address, and phone number fields. (You would be amazed that MANY businesses FAIL at this most basic requirement.) The SAME business details must be included on the GBP and website, and other listings.
The FREE first step: The FULL Competitor Scan
You Can Accurately Measure Your Current Rank with a FREE
As shown above, the Competitor Scan generates a composite score - 0 to 100 - across FOUR variables:
Your Google Business Profile is scored on completeness and accuracy.
Your Google Reviews are compared to the competition based on quantity, quality (that is, average "stars"), and recency (with old reviews deleted, and more weight given for the latest reviews.)
Your website: Is it complete, accurate with matches to the search term, and include recent updates?
This also now includes Search Engine Optimization scores that are valued by Google's "web spiders" AND the search functionality used by voice searches and AI chatbots.
Shoppers rely heavily on google reviews. Often they are comparing identical products or services from two or more providers. Reviews (quality and quantity) are often the deciding factor - with choices made in SECONDS.
What OTHERS say about your business has 10 TIMES the credibility of anything you say!
Google also includes reviews when ranking your business in the search results - but adds the three other primary weighting factors. In the next articles, I will discuss EACH of the factors in depth.
For now, remember that this Competitor Scan is the FIRST STEP. We need a measurement of the four ranking factors. This creates a baseline to start improving your search engine ranking.
Whatever factor shows the lowest score indicates the immediate priority. The Good News is that reviews are often the defined factor that shows the most dramatic improvement. See the related article about Automating Review Requests, Replies, and Reactivation.)
Because this is an audit at a point in time, we need to run the same Competitor Scan again in 60 to 90 days to gauge progress and reassess the NEXT priority. This is a never-ending process! You must accept the importance of your Google ranking and cooperate if you wish to see improvement - while also acknowledging that your fiercest competitors are not standing still. While you are making updates, they are also seeking to maintain or boost their rank.
You have "inside information" that your competition doesn't.
Click HERE to generate Your FREE Competitor Scan.
(Use the Option: "Connect Google to unlock the full scan")
You will IMMEIDATELY receive the 4-part score for your company.
There is NO cost, NO credit card required, NO catch!
You will have a current "snapshot" of which areas need immediate attention,
and an overall composite score that you can compare again later.
Your Competitor Scan is fast and free. You can use this tool to gain an accurate view of where you stand in comparison to your local competitors. There is NO cost and NO obligation. *Make sure that you choose the option: Connect to Google for the full scan.
Pay SPECIAL attention to your visibility in AI searches. These searches, online and using VOICE chats, are growing DAILY! It is important to note that ChatGPT, Google Gemini and the other bots only provide ONE best recommendation versus a Top Three result or pages of SERPs! It is an ALL or NOTHING reality!
If you don't already have and display your Google review link to customers,
contact me IMMEDIATELY!!!
I can generate a QR code and email it back to you - and/or provide table cards, business cards, etc!!!
QR code linked to your Google reviews
Stay tuned for more specific strategies to maximize customer referrals and retention. In upcoming articles I will discuss your Google Business Profile in more depth, including how to "optimize" the four primary factors used in the ranking protocol. We will also cover the work flow required, including how to use the latest tech to automate both the request for reviews, post timely responses to your reviews, and continuously update your Google Business Profile.
Created with © systeme.io